Skip to content
Left
Continue shopping
Your Order
You have no items in your cart
create
arts & crafts
build
decor
music
explore
books
nature
science
travel fun
grow
bath
dolls
infants
toddlers
learn
early learning
games
puzzles
school gear
play
active
little fun
stuffed animals
vehicles
pretend
dress up
figures
house & kitchen
puppets
shop by
licensed
bluey
curious george
disney
harry potter
minecraft
paw patrol
pokemon
pusheen
sesame street
star wars
thomas the train
category
active
arts & crafts
dolls
games
music
puzzles
science
stuffed animals
vehicles
SEE ALL CATEGORIES
brand
thinking putty
tattoos
everything else!
blind boxes
buttons & magnets
classics
fidget & squish
keychains
pens, pencils & more!
slime
stickers
Home
/
thinking putty
thinking putty
availability:
All
Portland Store
Portsmouth Store
Sort by:
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old
Sort by:
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old
Submit
Cosmic Glows Infinite Nebula Thinking Putty
$15.00
Glowbrights Enchanting Unicorn Thinking Putty
$15.00
Glowbrights Mermaid Tail Thinking Putty
$15.00
Hide Inside! Arcade Adventure Thinking Putty
$15.00
Hide Inside! Gnome Home Thinking Putty
$15.00
Hide Inside! Party Animals Thinking Putty
$15.00
Holiday Ugly Sweater Thinking Putty
$15.00
Hypercolors Magic Dragon Thinking Putty
$15.00
Liquid Glass Crystal Clear Thinking Putty
$15.00
Liquid Glass Falling Water Thinking Putty
$15.00
Magnetic Storms Earth Thinking Putty
$15.00
Magnetic Storms Tidal Wave Thinking Putty
$15.00
Mini Color Shock Coral Reef Thinking Putty
$4.00
Mini Color Shock Eternal Flame Thinking Putty
$4.00
Mini Glow Aurora Sky Thinking Putty
$4.00
Mini Holiday Merry & Bright Thinking Putty
$4.00
Mini Holiday Stocking Stuffer Thinking Putty
$4.00
Mini Holiday Twinkling Tree Thinking Putty
$4.00
Mini Holo Moon Light Thinking Putty
$4.00
Mini Hypercolor Night Fall Thinking Putty
$4.00
Mini Lost Treasure Guardians Thinking Putty
$4.00
Mini Sunshine Piglet Thinking Putty
$4.00
Mini Sunshine Spring Frog Thinking Putty
$4.00
Mini Trendsetters Avocado Thinking Putty
$4.00
Mini Trendsetters Bounce Bot Thinking Putty
$4.00
Mini Trendsetters Cryptocurrency Thinking Putty
$4.00
Mini Trendsetters Daydream Thinking Putty
$4.00
Mini Trendsetters Fairy Sprinkles Thinking Putty
$4.00
Mini Trendsetters Funky Fidget Thinking Putty
$4.00
Mini Trendsetters Mystic Crystal Thinking Putty
$4.00
Mini Trendsetters Rock N Roll Thinking Putty
$4.00
Mini Trendsetters Rose Gold Thinking Putty
$4.00
Mini Trendsetters Skate Away Thinking Putty
$4.00
Mini Trendsetters Starfish Thinking Putty
$4.00
Mini Trendsetters Take A Taco Thinking Putty
$4.00
Mini Trick or Treat Goodie Bag Thinking Putty
$4.00
54 results
Left
1
2
Right